You are viewing a free summary from Descrybe.ai. For citation checking, legal issue analysis, and other advanced tools, explore our Legal Research Toolkit — not free, but close.

Pruden v. Herbert Contractors, Inc.

Citations: 988 So. 2d 135; 2008 Fla. App. LEXIS 12891; 2008 WL 2901344Docket: No. 1D07-3319

Court: District Court of Appeal of Florida; July 30, 2008; Florida; State Appellate Court

Narrative Opinion Summary

In this case, the claimant appealed a decision by the Judge of Compensation Claims (JCC) denying interest on attorney’s fees from the date benefits were ordered. The claimant argued that, under section 55.03, Florida Statutes, interest should accrue from the compensation order date, citing that the 2003 amendments to section 440.34 imply attorney's fees are tied to awarded benefits. However, the court highlighted that attorney’s fees under chapter 440 are not self-executing and require JCC approval, as mandated by section 440.105(3)(c). The claimant's reliance on section 55.03, concerning civil judgments, was found inapplicable since the JCC's authority is strictly statutory and does not encompass automatic enforcement of attorney fees. Citing precedent, the court affirmed that no statutory provision allows for attorney fees until approved by the JCC, thus interest cannot accrue prior to this approval. Consequently, the court upheld the JCC's order denying the claimant's request for interest, with all concurring judges agreeing on the decision.

Legal Issues Addressed

Application of Section 55.03, Florida Statutes

Application: The claimant's argument for accruing interest based on section 55.03, which pertains to civil judgments, was rejected as inapplicable in the context of workers' compensation attorney fees.

Reasoning: The claimant sought interest based on section 55.03, which pertains to civil judgments, but the court emphasized that a JCC's authority is limited to what is statutorily conferred and does not extend beyond that.

Authority of Judge of Compensation Claims

Application: The JCC's authority is limited to statutory provisions, emphasizing that attorney's fees require JCC approval and are not automatically granted or enforced.

Reasoning: The court emphasized that a JCC's authority is limited to what is statutorily conferred and does not extend beyond that.

Interest on Attorney's Fees in Workers’ Compensation Cases

Application: The court determined that interest on attorney's fees does not accrue until the JCC approves the fee amount, as there is no self-executing right to such fees under chapter 440.

Reasoning: The court concluded that there is no entitlement to interest on attorney fees in workers’ compensation cases until the JCC has approved the fee amount.