You are viewing a free summary from Descrybe.ai. For citation checking, legal issue analysis, and other advanced tools, explore our Legal Research Toolkit — not free, but close.

Butler Cty. Bar Ass'n v. Portman

Citations: 116 Ohio St. 3d 1450; 878 N.E.2d 28Docket: 2007-1570

Court: Ohio Supreme Court; December 20, 2007; Ohio; State Supreme Court

Narrative Opinion Summary

The judicial opinion involves a disciplinary proceeding against an attorney, identified by their registration number, who faced potential permanent disbarment. The Board of Commissioners on Grievances and Discipline initially recommended disbarment, leading to an interim suspension by the court, effective immediately, pending further evaluation of mitigating circumstances, including a mental health assessment. The attorney filed objections, prompting the court to remand the case for further consideration. During the suspension, the respondent is prohibited from practicing law and must undertake specific continuing legal education focused on professional conduct. The attorney is also required to notify clients, ensure the return of client property, and refund unearned fees. Additionally, the respondent must document compliance with these directives and submit proof to the court and disciplinary authorities. The opinion outlines detailed procedural obligations, including notification of adverse parties, surrender of registration credentials, and ongoing updates on contact information. The order emphasizes strict adherence to documentation and communication protocols to ensure transparency and accountability throughout the suspension period.

Legal Issues Addressed

Client Notification and Duties

Application: The respondent is mandated to inform clients of the suspension and manage all client-related matters promptly.

Reasoning: He must also reimburse any amounts awarded by the Clients’ Security Fund within 90 days and notify his clients about the suspension, instructing them to seek alternative legal representation.

Disbarment and Interim Suspension

Application: The court recommended permanent disbarment but initially imposed an interim suspension pending further review of mitigating factors.

Reasoning: The court ordered an interim suspension of the respondent from practicing law, effective immediately, until a further recommendation from the Board.

Documentation and Compliance

Application: The respondent is required to document compliance with the court's orders and maintain communication updates with relevant legal bodies.

Reasoning: Compliance with these requirements must be documented in an affidavit submitted to the court clerk and the Disciplinary Counsel of the Supreme Court, including proof of notice service and the affiant's address for communication.

Obligations During Suspension

Application: The respondent must cease practicing law, notify clients, and complete specific educational requirements during the suspension period.

Reasoning: The respondent is prohibited from practicing law... and is required to complete one hour of continuing legal education for each month of suspension, including specific instruction on professional conduct.