You are viewing a free summary from Descrybe.ai. For citation checking, legal issue analysis, and other advanced tools, explore our Legal Research Toolkit — not free, but close.

Board of Trade of the City of Chicago Et Al. v. Charles F. Clyne, United States District Attorney, Etc., Et Al.

Citation: 260 U.S. 704Docket: 701

Court: Supreme Court of the United States; November 13, 1922; Federal Supreme Court; Federal Appellate Court

Narrative Opinion Summary

The Supreme Court of the United States issued an order on December 4, 1922, regarding the Board of Trade of the City of Chicago and Charles F. Clyne, the U.S. District Attorney for the Northern District of Illinois. The court ordered a temporary preservation of the status quo while the case is pending, specifically enjoining Clyne from enforcing the Grain Futures Act for the duration of the case and for an additional 20 days thereafter. This injunction prohibits any criminal prosecution against members of the Board of Trade or their customers for violations of the Act occurring during this period. Additionally, Arthur C. Lueder, the postmaster of Chicago, is restrained from interfering with mail exchanges between Board members and their customers during the same timeframe. However, members of the Board are still required to maintain their records of contracts for future delivery as mandated by the Grain Futures Act throughout the pendency of this stay.

Legal Issues Addressed

Compliance with Record-Keeping Requirements Despite Injunction

Application: Despite the injunction against enforcement, Board members are required to continue maintaining records of contracts for future delivery as required by the Grain Futures Act.

Reasoning: However, members of the Board are still required to maintain their records of contracts for future delivery as mandated by the Grain Futures Act throughout the pendency of this stay.

Injunction Against Enforcement of Statutory Provisions

Application: The Supreme Court issued an injunction preventing the enforcement of the Grain Futures Act by the U.S. District Attorney while the case is pending, ensuring no criminal prosecution against Board of Trade members during this period.

Reasoning: The court ordered a temporary preservation of the status quo while the case is pending, specifically enjoining Clyne from enforcing the Grain Futures Act for the duration of the case and for an additional 20 days thereafter.

Protection of Communication Channels During Legal Proceedings

Application: The Court's order restrains the Chicago postmaster from interfering with mail exchanges between Board members and their customers, ensuring the continuation of communication during the legal stay.

Reasoning: Additionally, Arthur C. Lueder, the postmaster of Chicago, is restrained from interfering with mail exchanges between Board members and their customers during the same timeframe.